Turkey Hill Recalls Ice Cream after Labeling Issue Exposes Consumers to Health Problems

October 12, 2016 | By admin

Turkey Hill Dairy, a Pennsylvania-based company that produces and distributes ice cream throughout the country, recently issued a major product recall due to a labeling mistake.

Turkey Hill sells ice cream in New Jersey stores, so NJ consumers should pay attention to the recall notice.

During the manufacturing process, a labeling issue meant that Dutch Chocolate Premium Ice Cream tubs were being topped off with a Rocky Road Premium Ice Cream lid. In addition to resulting in many unsatisfied customers, the mislabeling had the potential to cause serious health problems for consumers. That’s because the Dutch Chocolate ice cream and the Rocky Road ice cream have different ingredients and could expose customers with allergies or other types of food sensitivities to health complications. For instance, the Turkey Hill Rocky Road ice cream contains eggs and almonds not listed among the ingredients for the Dutch Chocolate ice cream – anyone with allergies to eggs or almonds would be at risk of suffering an allergic reaction and might not realize it until after eating the ice cream.

The Turkey Hill recall affects Dutch Chocolate Premium Ice Cream tubs. Consumers should check the bottom of the package and see if the ice cream has a sell-by date of May 23, 2017. Anyone who has purchased one of the recalled food products can contact Turkey Hill Dairy to arrange for a replacement or the issuance of a full refund.

At this time, there have not been any reports of anyone sustaining an illness or suffering an allergic reaction as a result of consuming the recalled Turkey Hill ice cream.

For more information, read the Press of Atlantic City article, “Turkey Hill Issues Recall on Ice Cream Packages That Could Contain Nuts.”


If you or a loved one suffered an illness due to consumption of contaminated food, you should speak with a qualified product liability attorney as soon as possible. The experienced, knowledgeable personal injury and product liability lawyers at Lombardi & Lombardi can help you get the compensation you need, want, and deserve. Contact us now to schedule a free consultation at one of our offices in Edison, Brick or Freehold, New Jersey.


1862 Oak Tree Road
Edison, NJ 08820

T. (732) 906-1500


10 Parsonage Rd.
Edison, NJ 08837

T. (732) 205-0580


119 Chambers Bridge Rd.
Brick, NJ 08723

T. (848) 232-2831


402 West Main Street
Freehold, NJ 07728

T. (732 )780-0569

Point Pleasant

62 Broadway
Point Pleasant Beach, NJ 08742

T. (732 )734-4490

Our Awards Our Awards Our Awards Our Awards
Lombardi and Lombardi, P.A., serves clients in Newark, Elizabeth, Edison, Woodbridge, Toms River, Brick, Middletown, Union City, Piscataway, New Brunswick, Perth Amboy, East Brunswick, Plainfield, Jackson, Sayreville, Linden, South Brunswick, Marlboro, Freehold, Manalapan, Westfield, Rahway, Carteret, Somerset, Old Bridge, South Plainfield, Cranford, Avenel, Iselin, Clark, Red Bank, Point Pleasant, Middlesex County, Essex County, Ocean County, Monmouth County, Union County, Somerset County and throughout New Jersey.

© 2017 Lombardi and Lombardi, P.A. All Rights Reserved. Site Map. Privacy Policy.